“People”
Jule Styne and Bob Merrill, Funny Girl,
1964
Performer:
Barbara Streisand, original Broadway recording
Jule Styne and Bob Merrill, Funny Girl,
1964
Performer:
Barbara Streisand, reportedly her last performance in the musica
Jule Styne and Bob Merrill, Funny Girl,
1964
Performer:
Dionne Warwick, 1965
Jule Styne and Bob Merrill, Funny Girl, 1964
Performer:
Tony Bennett, 1969
Jule Styne and Bob Merrill, Funny Girl,
1964
Performer:
Shirley Bassey, 1979
I
have always wondered why one of the most innovative musical theater composers
of all time, Stephen Sondheim, insists upon real end rhymes for his lyrics,
while the more “old-school” composer and lyricist, Jule Styne and Bob Merrill,
explored some new territory in the shimmering ballad, “People,” which depends
far more on the repetition of words—“people,” “children,” “lovers,” etc—to
convey its message, relying on only on occasional end rhyme and even then
employing mostly internal rhyme: “pride”/”hide”/”inside” and
“thirst/first.”
People
People who need people
Are the luckiest people in the world
We're children, needing other children
And yet letting a grown-up pride
Hide all the need inside
Acting more like children than children
Lovers, very special people
They're the luckiest people in the world
With one person
One very special person
A feeling deep in your soul
Says you were half now you're whole
No more hunger and thirst
But first be a person who needs people
People who need people
Are the luckiest people in the world
This song, rather than pushing its themes to the center of its lines, surrounded by end rhymes, boldly makes its statements about people, love, and the world, straight out, lingering upon the repetitions a bit like Wagner might have, instead of speeding ahead with an incredible locomotive of impossible rhymes and word choices the way Frank Loesser and Sondheim might.
It is almost unthinkable that director Garson Kanin wanted to cut the piece; although I do agree with him that it's probably not the kind of song Fanny Brice might ever have sung.
The music here and lyrics here become so
pliable that one can interpret the song through numerous musical genres—love
ballad, jazz riff, big band belter—and it encourages the singer to improvise:
Streisand herself has interpreted it in various ways throughout the years. I
prefer her original Broadway stage version, but I must admit as she aged, the
song became even more velvety and dusky. It was, after all, a kind of seduction
number even in the original, where she tests out her feelings for Nicky
Arnstein, and seduces him into considering a love affair.
I’ve included four other interpretations
of the song, by Dionne Warwick, Tony Bennett, and Shirley
Bassey, to show the song’s range. But Streisand’s slow-version ballad about
what she wants out of life is by far the best.
Los
Angeles, August 29, 2017
Legend has it that Kanin didn't really do a lot of 'directing' as the show was in trouble before coming to NYC. It was Robbins who was brought it to nurture it to the show it became when it opened at the Winter Garden. Who knows who really wanted to cut it. It did slow somethings down and thank God it did! Wish we still had some pics of Sydney Chaplain the original Nick. Another legend was that THEY didn't get along so he was paid the run of his contract NOT to go to work.
ReplyDelete